The Wonderland Board

Spoiler warning: Screenshots of all MOFI adventures lie within, including post-game adventures.

Wonderland's Mysterious Island's Adventures Tier List

https://cadence.moe/mofi-tier-list

Using the website

You must use a computer and a mouse cursor, not a phone touchscreen.
Drag items to re-order them into categories.
Click an item to see its picture larger (the picture opens in a new tab).
When you hover over an item, it shows the adventure name and a # number. If you use CMD 8 and set Data1 to that number, you'll be teleported into the adventure. You can use this to inspect an adventure if you forgot what it's like or how it's played.
If you close the page, it will remember your rankings for the next time you open it again.

For the tier lists of other games, I used these criteria to decide where to rank things. You don't have to follow these criteria, you can put adventures wherever you want for whatever reason. But if you're looking for some direction, here they are:

• S: Brilliant adventure.
• A: Very enjoyable adventure.
• B: Good adventure. It has ideas and I would replay it.
• C: Not interesting, but it fits a purpose. Not unenjoyable.
• D: Not good at all, but also not actively bad.
• F: This adventure actively repels me and makes me not want to play it. It's like it was deliberately made to feel as horrible as possible.
• X: Not an adventure.

Have fun!

Share your results by taking a screenshot and posting it in this thread!

https://cadence.moe/mofi-tier-list

All my tier lists

• WA1 viewtopic.php?f=1&t=28243
• MOFI viewtopic.php?f=1&t=28538
• POTZ viewtopic.php?f=1&t=28253

Tier list for all unused MOFI adventures soon

Oh nice to see Wonderland getting this meme/trope.

Um where's levels 6-10?

Here.

In the past, MOFI designers posted levels for the game and the testers voted on few criteria from 1-10

Visual/Design
Fun/Playability
Difficulty

I was thinking of rating all MOFI levels on that criteria but HOLD ON, why isn't this used for any custom adventures on the forum, it will be epic if someone posts adventure and the rest rate it with those criteria, and give feedback to the creator

Here's an example for a vote for one of my favorite adventures in MOFI, Underground Stream

Visual/Design: 9/10 - Amazing but there are few weird walls, other than that its very atmospheric
Fun/Playability: 7/10 - The only kinda annoying part is the turtle puzzle on top, it takes a lot of time and you can't do anything past shooting pop
Difficulty: 4/10 - Not that hard, few tricky grow parts and timings etc

My tier list.
Don't Leave Me Behind would be A-tier if not for the unfair bonus that doesn't telegraph itself well, forcing you to very likely restart the entire level. Trying to get Gold was simply frustrating.

X is reserved for levels I did not rank.

|Cookie| wrote: Tue Aug 22, 2023 2:32 pm My tier list.
Don't Leave Me Behind would be A-tier if not for the unfair bonus that doesn't telegraph itself well, forcing you to very likely restart the entire level. Trying to get Gold was simply frustrating.

X is reserved for levels I did not rank.

Nice, but here's mine, a more unbiased and universally accepted Tier-list.
It's a joke put your pitchforks down.

ab-47 wrote: Tue Aug 22, 2023 3:49 pmNice, but here's mine, a more unbiased and universally accepted Tier-list.

Don't forget to lock your doors tonight.

|Cookie| wrote: Tue Aug 22, 2023 5:58 pm

ab-47 wrote: Tue Aug 22, 2023 3:49 pmNice, but here's mine, a more unbiased and universally accepted Tier-list.

Don't forget to lock your doors tonight.

XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD I AGREEZ

What does X rating even mean Cadence

I just used it as worse than F because IDK

is it supposed to be like 'unknown' or 'weird'?

Ash thinks it means weird apparently

X is whatever you want it if you specify it in your post, I guess.

Wonderman109 wrote: Tue Aug 22, 2023 10:06 pmI just used it as worse than F because IDK

I know everyone has different opinions and all but I'm curious about your reasoning for putting levels such as Scritter Maze, Lots of Locks or Lost in the Mines on the same tier as levels such as mystery island, and how are The Star Key and The Pit on a higher tier when they're 99% walking

i know they are technically part of the main game albeit from the secret area but wont it be fair the 8 secret adventures to be part of seperate tierlist along with the other archived unused adventures (theyre around 200 lol) also the potz tierlist doesnt have the final secret levels too

for example ice flower cave has 6 versions, and 3 of them have huge gameplay impacting changes. i dont think everyone will go through all but i am curious how one level progresses from the first version to the last in terms of ranking, also IFCv4 is cooler than IFCv5 which is cooler than IFCv6 imo xddddd

|Cookie| wrote: Wed Aug 23, 2023 1:00 am X is whatever you want it if you specify it in your post, I guess.

Wonderman109 wrote: Tue Aug 22, 2023 10:06 pmI just used it as worse than F because IDK

I know everyone has different opinions and all but I'm curious about your reasoning for putting levels such as Scritter Maze, Lots of Locks or Lost in the Mines on the same tier as levels such as mystery island, and how are The Star Key and The Pit on a higher tier when they're 99% walking

I didn't think it through a great deal ngl

SCritter Maze is the temple one that's really annoying, Lots of Locks is also really annoying, and Lost in the Mines is super annoying. I don't like puzzles with scaredy or small creatures because they are too random and too finicky. Star Key is short and impactful, The Pit (is this the sundog mine one or the sandpit one?) is atmospheric in either case and has a feeling of approaching a goal.

nasko222 wrote: Wed Aug 23, 2023 1:25 am i know they are technically part of the main game albeit from the secret area but wont it be fair the 8 secret adventures to be part of seperate tierlist along with the other archived unused adventures (theyre around 200 lol) also the potz tierlist doesnt have the final secret levels too

for example ice flower cave has 6 versions, and 3 of them have huge gameplay impacting changes. i dont think everyone will go through all but i am curious how one level progresses from the first version to the last in terms of ranking, also IFCv4 is cooler than IFCv5 which is cooler than IFCv6 imo xddddd

I mean I feel like variety is the stuff of life. I don't know if I'd want to play 6 versions of one level given that I often make 6 myself through the test and replay process of level making.